Re: testing paper open 14" air cleaner to the same K/N

From: Vincent Heckathorn (victorylane@iwaynet.net)
Date: Mon Sep 14 1998 - 00:49:07 EDT


OOPS I am using 0W30 Mobil 1, not 0W40!!!!!!!!!!

Colin

Vincent Heckathorn wrote:

> I have been using a 14" open K/N air cleaner for a while and am going to
> do a test between the same and a 14" paper element.
> The test will be on how well each of them do on filtering as well as gas
> mileage and performance.
> I will be using each filter for 4000 miles and then change the oil and
> get an oil analysis performed.
> The first step has been done ( 14" K/N ).
> My average gas mileage is around 12.5 city 17.5 highway.
> Performance is just the seat of your pants dyno, I haven't been able to
> get to the drag strip yet.
> I will be sending the oil out on tuesday, it will take about a week to
> get the results back.
> My initial feel is that with the paper filter there isn't much if any
> difference in performance and sound, but a tenth or two would be hard to
> tell with out going to the strip.
> I am using Mobil 1 0w40 oil along with a Mobil 1 oil filter.
> The paper element air filter is a 14"x3" Purolater.
> My main concern is the filtering ability of the K/N. In the past I have
> used them and have always seen high levels of Silicone ( dirt ) in my
> oil analysis compared to a paper element filter.
> As we all know dirt will kill an engine. I know that a lot of you will
> be giving me hell over this, but time will tell whether a $2.50 cheap
> filter will perform as well, and out filter the High priced K/N.
> FWIW, I usually change oil and filter at around 8000 miles with a oil
> analysis at 4000 miles to keep an eye on everything.
> most of my cars/trucks have gone over the 150000 mile mark with out any
> problems at all and usually never have to add any oil between changes.
>
> Colin H.



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Fri Jun 20 2003 - 12:09:49 EDT