RE: Synthetic Oil

From: Smith L. W. Nash (railway@mindspring.com)
Date: Sun Sep 14 1997 - 22:08:22 EDT


------ =_NextPart_000_01BCC15C.3D4F7220
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

I've been using Mobil 1 for awhile now and have no leaks to speak of. I =
have 90200+ miles and no leaks since changing over at 85K. Although it =
may be too soon to tell, the valve cover gaskets are original so that =
will be the acid test on leaks. Since it doesn't leave a varnish as it =
breaks down, it won't do as much damage as it cooks. My grandfather has =
been using Mobil products since he owned his first car, a 1928 Pontiac =
Coupe. He swears by it still.

Smitty Nash
'92 Dak 3.9L Magnum
90K+

----------
From: Gary Ludwick
Sent: Sunday, September 14, 1997 4:30 PM
To: 'Dakota list'
Subject: Synthetic Oil

I've noticed discussion here from time to time from folks using =
synthetic
oil.
I also have a Mercedes, and yesterday received the current issue of the
Mercedes Club's magazine in which there is a long discussion among
mechanics, tech experts and MB service personnel on the merits of using
synthetic oil.

In a nutshell...NO appreciable benefit.

The only measurable benefit appears to be in SOME cases, a slight =
increase
in mileage...and that is negated by the high cost of the oil. The only
other benefit noted is easier starting in EXTREMELY cold environments.

One of the experts on the panel runs an oil analysis business. Does a =
lot
of work for large fleet companies, trucking lines, as well as =
individuals.=20
 In a database of thousands of users, they could find no difference in
engine wear rates between regular and synthetic oil.

Synthetics attack some gasket materials and cause increased leakage. =
This
happens in some new vehicles. On older cars and trucks, as seals shrink =
&
harden, synthetics are MUCH more likely to leak. As one participant =
stated,
"Given the quality of motor oils today, synthetics have no place in the
market. With conventional oils, we have engines going 5,6,or 700,000
miles. What more could you want?!"

One other point: At least with Mercedes, you still must meet regular
mileage oil change requirements...even if you're using synthetic, or =

------ =_NextPart_000_01BCC15C.3D4F7220
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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=

------ =_NextPart_000_01BCC15C.3D4F7220--



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Fri Jun 20 2003 - 12:07:52 EDT